I played a Little Lute this past weekend

topic posted Mon, October 15, 2007 - 9:29 PM by  Achbar
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
I was at an SCA event and this guy had a very familiar instrument. I thought it was an Oud at first. I own an Oud and thought we could jam later. Not I saw the frets and Knew it was a Lute. The own told me this Lute was a piece of Dung. he only Paid 400.00 and got it from Middle Eastern Mfg. he told me to stay clear of them. He had to do work just to make it playable. I imagine it would be a good instrument to [practice on if you had nothing else



Achbar
posted by:
Achbar
Charlotte
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: I played a Little Lute this past weekend

    Wed, October 24, 2007 - 1:27 PM
    I know the kind of lute you mean. They are commonly referred to as Ebay lutes by lute players, because that's where they end up. They are poorly constructed, are way too heavy, have terrible action, and sound like rubber bands on a cigar box. You often see them in productions of Taming of the Shrew where Katerina has smashed a lute over her music teacher's head. The props manager takes an Ebay lute, cuts a hole through the soundboard and bowl, and puts it over the actor's shoulders for the scene. Probably the best use for them. I haven't heard one myself, but all of the feedback I've heard or read is uniformly bad.

    The problem with practicing on a lute that bad is that you are coping with a bad instrument at a time when you are trying to develop good playing techniques. And you are getting terrible feedback from the instrument, which sounds cruddy no matter what you do. I'm not saying that the lutes I've built myself are masterpieces, but they are at a good enough level to be satisfying instruments for a beginner.

    You would be much better off looking for a used instrument at about the same price. On web sites I have seen used instruments made by not-well-known luthiers from the late 70s for about $400-500. They won't be prizes, but you will be much happier with them.
    • Re: I played a Little Lute this past weekend

      Thu, October 25, 2007 - 4:34 AM
      You would be much better off looking for a used instrument at about the same price. On web sites I have seen used instruments made by not-well-known luthiers from the late 70s for about $400-500. They won't be prizes, but you will be much happier with them.



      Thanks, I appreciate this advice

Recent topics in "Lute lovers"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Learning Lute? Achbar 1 January 13, 2009
My Van de Geest lute Anthony 2 January 19, 2008
Need some encouragement Jim 1 November 21, 2007
Playing Lute Achbar 3 October 15, 2007
Musts for the lutenist Jim 0 July 19, 2007